We have seen the bookshelf VS soundbar battle for too long. Now, it’s time for a definite answer on which one you should choose.
Bookshelf speakers produce incredibly high sound quality, creating a genuinely cinematic sensation. They’re ideal for use with a home theatre system. They are a great option irrespective of the available space or room size.
On the other hand, Soundbars have a very slim and compact form. The connecting process is simple, and you have a variety of options from which to choose, so bear your television’s characteristics in mind.
Let’s dive into the details here!
🤔 What Is A Bookshelf Speaker, And What Are Its Key Features?
Bookshelf speakers are not just for your bookcase; they should be kept on a rack, table, or pedestal, not on the ground. These are a little larger than PC loudspeakers and can fill a broader range of locations with sound.
They’re more convenient to place in your place than soundbars, and they appear a lot better than bookshelf speakers. Passive bookshelf speakers are an excellent option if you desire an accurate surround sound impression. If your home theatre system is old, or you want to try something fresh, these single speakers are ideal.
Bookshelf Speaker Pros
Also Read: Polk T15 Bookshelf Speaker Review
Bookshelf Speaker Cons
🎯 What Is A Soundbar, & What Are Its Key Features?
A soundbar is an all-in-one audio system with multiple speakers that offer high-quality television audio. Soundbars benefit from saving space and money while providing stereo sound or immersive sound quality.
The compact audio elements are easy to attach to other gadgets and provide a dramatic audio experience for consumers. Most TVs are not soundproofed, so soundbars will provide you with an experience like in a theater.
Also Read: Bestisan Soundbar Reviews
⚖ The Ultimate Showdown Between Bookshelf Speakers and Soundbars
1️⃣ Sound Performance
Sound performance is arguably the most crucial factor when comparing driven stereo bookshelf speakers to soundbars. You must also think about the audio system as a whole.
If you include bookshelf speakers in your audio system, the sound quality will be superior to what you now have. Soundbars are a significant upgrade from the TV’s built-in speakers, and because they are so simple to set up, they could be a very appealing and excellent alternative for your home cinema.
Because the bookshelf speaker’s structural components help in the organic outcome of audio impulses, they surpass soundbars at comparable prices. Nonetheless, be sure you choose the best solution for you.
When comparing the separate speaker, a pair of bookshelf stereo speakers will almost certainly outperform a soundbar regarding clarity, powerful sound, etc.
2️⃣ Speaker Placement
The exact chamber dynamics in the home cinema area will be an additional factor when deciding whether bookshelf speakers or a soundbar is better for you.
While online guidance might be helpful in some cases, it can only stretch so far, given the wide range of home cinema rooms.
For instance, if you’re in a more extensive home theatre area, you may wish to utilize bookshelf speakers with just an amplifier to enhance the audio. It will result in a richer audio experience. However, a soundbar with numerous streams and a subwoofer would suffice in a tiny or mid-sized home cinema room.
3️⃣ Frequency Response
One of the essential qualities of a speaker to examine is frequency response. The frequency response, also known as frequency range, indicates how higher or lower the speakers can go. The more frequency response there is, the better.
Any bookshelf speakers that achieve a frequency of 50Hz or below are adequate and do not require subwoofers. On the other hand, soundbars may produce the minimum human audio frequency, 20Hz. The woofer of a soundbar also indicates a frequency spectrum of 2000Hz-20000Hz.
Woofers, medium spectrum drivers, and tweeters are the three major drivers in speakers. A separate subwoofer is occasionally used to improve the bass sound. The size of an audio system, on the other hand, does matter.
Large audio systems amplify music and add a bass response, resulting in a more precise and powerful sound.
Bookshelf speakers often include 5″-6.25″ woofers and 75″-1.4″ tweeters to provide a large soundstage for listening to music. On the other hand, soundbars come with varying amounts of built-in tweeters, and you’ll almost always discover a soundbar with something like a subwoofer.
5️⃣ Sensitivity Rating
Many people are unaware that speaker sensitivity is among the most critical aspects in determining how loud and crisp a speaker will play.
Most bookshelf speakers have a sensitivity range of 88dB to 92dB. A value of more than 92dB is considered excellent.
Soundbars, on the other hand, typically have a similar sensitivity rating. The larger the audio output, the better the sensitivity rating.
6️⃣ Power Rating
If you want loud, reverberating sounds like rap, hardcore, or pop, 200W should be enough. If you appreciate symphonic, jazz, funk, or hip-hop, 50W will be sufficient. A bookshelf speaker’s or powered speaker’s output is divided into maximum/peak power & RMS power.
Did You Know?
A constant power supply in typical conditions is referred to as RMS. It is used to match amplifier specifications. The maximum force a loudspeaker can deliver quickly is called peak power.
It doesn’t work with the amplifier. It’s critical to evaluate RMS and Peak Power while deciding between 2 rear speakers. The overall applied watts are the soundbar’s power supply.
The watts are merely the power consumption. The power supply ranges between 20 and 30 percent and 80 and 90 percent.
The last technological aspect we’ll discuss is connectivity. You’ll need to connect your bookshelf or powered speakers to your sound device and television. On the other hand, some soundbars provide wireless communication, such as Bluetooth.
Given the restricted bandwidth of wireless communication, including Bluetooth, you must accept that sound will always be delivered with denoising data compression. As a result, Bluetooth will reduce the high-quality audio to some extent.
However, using Bluetooth will lower sound quality (Spoiler Alert: Not so significant that you will feel the difference).
Bookshelf speakers are often less expensive than single soundbars keeping the quality aspect aside. However, when you realize that you’ll require an amplifier and a subwoofer to create the high-quality music you want, the budget range of a bookshelf speaker might be more.
You’ll also want a centre channel speaker to ensure the conversation isn’t lost due to the lack of one with your two bookshelf speakers.
You could add extra channels to a soundbar, which can hold numerous pairs of speakers, and a subwoofer that produces low-frequency audio signals may be better for you.
😍 Are Bookshelf Speakers Better Than a Soundbar for Home Audio?
You should be able to tell why one option is preferable for you to another after comparing a few areas. It all boils down to individual preference and the amount of money you’re willing to spend on your long-term home cinema needs.
If you’re an audiophile, you might be questioning the benefits of a soundbar versus a pair of high-quality bookshelf speakers. The reply is that a soundbar may be preferable based on the scale of your space and your particular preferences.
Consumers purchase soundbars primarily to boost the audio quality of their television sets. Even low-cost soundbars increase the audio quality of television and deliver a spacious sound that covers every corner of the room.
We observed that bookshelf speakers outperform soundbars in audio quality from a technological standpoint. Wireless speakers are intended to be built to integrate various technologies that a soundbar simply cannot reproduce.
However, you ought to be conscious that soundbars have a few drawbacks. They require more space and more batteries than a pair of bookshelf speakers.
If you’re short on area, bookshelf speakers can be better. Soundbars could also be more challenging to set up than bookshelf speaker systems. You may require a dedicated receiver or amp with a soundbar, while you might plug your bookshelf speakers into an established receiver.
Overall, I feel that bookshelf speakers should be the right choice. Suppose you genuinely desire the best sound system. It would be best to consider investing in a nice pair of bookshelf speakers, which will deliver higher audio quality, mainly due to the several aspects we highlighted.
💡 Bookshelf Speaker VS Soundbar: FAQs
1. Do you need an amp for bookshelf speakers?
Active bookshelf speakers do not require an amplifier, which is not the case with passive speakers. Passive speakers do not have an amp built-in, but active bookshelf speakers do.
2. What does a soundbar do?
A soundbar is a music gadget that can also be used as a loudspeaker. The device can be linked to the primary power supply source and produces impressive acoustic sound.
3. Tv speakers Vs Soundbars: Which one is better?
We could see that TV speakers are better for music enjoyment than soundbars. Soundbars are far superior to speakers whenever watching movies or listening to music.
4. Should I add a sub to my bookshelf speakers?
Although a subwoofer isn’t required for speakers to work, adding one to a set of speakers, notably smaller bookshelf sound systems, is worth it.
5. How many channels should a soundbar have?
The most popular channel versions, on the other hand, range from 2.0 to 9.1.4.
About the Author
Rach Wellard is the driving force behind Sound & Solitude. Her mission is to help you discover the profound impact of sound in your daily life and to explore the beauty of solitude. With a deep passion for the connection between soundscapes and emotions, she brings a unique blend of expertise and personal dedication to our platform.
Rach understands that every individual's auditory journey is unique, and she’s here to guide you every step of the way. As a devoted audiophile, Rach’s discerning ear carefully selects the most exceptional products that align with your desires for Sound or Solitude. In a world filled with noise and chaos, Sound & Solitude serves as your sanctuary.
Rach’s journey as an autistic individual with a heightened sensitivity to sound fuels our commitment to creating an inclusive space where everyone can find solace while enjoying the meaningful sounds in their lives. Her understanding of diverse sensory needs enables us to offer personalized recommendations and insights, ensuring that your chosen audio equipment not only meets technical criteria but also resonates with your unique sensory preferences. And if you simply seek the best sound possible, Rach has you covered.
At Sound & Solitude, authenticity is our foundation. We provide unbiased reviews and comparisons because you deserve nothing but the truth. Our reviews are meticulously crafted, drawing upon Rach’s deep understanding of audio technology and the human experience in the Sound and Solitude realms. Whether you're searching for noise-cancelling headphones to immerse yourself in music or seeking a gaming headset that transports you to virtual worlds, you can rely on our reviews and personally tested comparisons to find the best equipment for your specific needs. Explore our carefully curated content, from the latest wireless audio advancements to tips for creating your ideal auditory retreat.
Let Sound & Solitude be your companion in your quest for perfect sound, rich experiences, and beautiful serenity. Join Rach as she redefines the way you listen, connecting you to the power of Sound and the Solitude it brings. Together, we'll evolve into your trusted platform for all things related to Sound & Solitude.